Border Protection Bill
Introduction
Late on the night of August 29, 2001, the federal government introduced the "Border Protection" bill into the House. The government party is the "Liberal Party" (the miss naming of which is Orwellian). The bill was introduced with no warning.
I find it incredible that a bill like this could be introduced into any democratic parliament. Even more incredible was that anybody would vote for it. Yet it passed the House and failed only in the Senate. In my opinion the fact that passed the House hammers yet another nail in the "Responsible Government" doctrine (assuming there's room for another nail, of course).
The bill is included below. Read it and ask you self whether the people who voted it up can be considered democrats.
The Bill
Voting Record
The House
Ayes............ 73
Noes............ 61
Majority......... 12
AYES
| Name | Electorate | Party Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| Abbott, A.J. | Warringah NSW | Liberal |
| Anderson, J.D. | Gwydir NSW | National |
| Andrews, K.J. | Menzies Vic | Liberal |
| Anthony, L.J. | Richmond NSW | National |
| Bailey, F.E. | McEwen Vic | Liberal |
| Baird, B.G. | Cook ,NSW | Liberal |
| Barresi, P.A. | Deakin ,Vic | Liberal |
| Bartlett, K.J. | Macquarie ,NSW | Liberal |
| Billson, B.F. | Dunkley ,Vic | Liberal |
| Bishop, B.K. | Mackellar ,NSW | Liberal |
| Bishop, J.I. | Curtin ,WA | Liberal |
| Brough, M.T. | Longman ,Qld | Liberal |
| Cadman, A.G. | Mitchell ,NSW | Liberal |
| Causley, I.R. | Page ,NSW | National |
| Charles, R.E. | La Trobe ,Vic | Liberal |
| Costello, P.H. | Higgins ,Vic | Liberal |
| Downer, A.J.G. | Mayo ,SA | Liberal |
| Draper, P. | Makin ,SA | Liberal |
| Elson, K.S. | Forde ,Qld | Liberal |
| Entsch, W.G. | Leichhardt ,Qld | Liberal |
| Fahey, J.J. | Macarthur ,NSW | Liberal |
| Forrest, J.A. | Mallee ,Vic | National |
| Gambaro, T. | Petrie ,Qld | Liberal |
| Gash, J. | Gilmore ,NSW | Liberal |
| Georgiou, P. | Kooyong ,Vic | Liberal |
| Haase, B.W. | Kalgoorlie ,WA | Liberal |
| Hardgrave, G.D. | Moreton ,Qld | Liberal |
| Hawker, D.P.M. | Wannon ,Vic | Liberal |
| Hockey, J.B. | North Sydney ,NSW | Liberal |
| Howard, J.W. | Bennelong ,NSW | Liberal |
| Hull, K.E. | Riverina ,NSW | National |
| Jull, D.F. | Fadden ,Qld | Liberal |
| Katter, R.C. | Kennedy ,Qld | None |
| Kelly, D.M. | Dawson ,Qld | National |
| Kelly, J.M. | Lindsay ,NSW | Liberal |
| Kemp, D.A. | Goldstein ,Vic | Liberal |
| Lawler, A.J. | Parkes ,NSW | National |
| Lieberman, L.S. | Indi ,Vic | Liberal |
| Lindsay, P.J. | Herbert ,Qld | Liberal |
| Lloyd, J.E. | Robertson ,NSW | Liberal |
| Macfarlane, I.E. | Groom ,Qld | Liberal |
| May, M.A. | McPherson ,Qld | Liberal |
| McArthur, S. | Corangamite ,Vic | Liberal |
| McGauran, P.J. | Gippsland ,Vic | National |
| Nairn, G. R. | Eden-Monaro ,NSW | Liberal |
| Nehl, G. B. | Cowper ,NSW | National |
| Nelson, B.J. | Bradfield ,NSW | Liberal |
| Neville, P.C. | Hinkler ,Qld | National |
| Pearce, C.J. | Aston ,Vic | Liberal |
| Prosser, G.D. | Forrest ,WA | Liberal |
| Pyne, C. | Sturt ,SA | Liberal |
| Reith, P.K. | Flinders ,Vic | Liberal |
| Ronaldson, M.J.C. | Ballarat ,Vic | Liberal |
| Ruddock, P.M. | Berowra ,NSW | Liberal |
| Schultz, A. | Hume ,NSW | Liberal |
| Scott, B.C. | Maranoa ,Qld | National |
| Secker, P.D. | Barker ,SA | Liberal |
| Slipper, P.N. | Fisher ,Qld | Liberal |
| Somlyay, A.M. | Fairfax ,Qld | Liberal |
| Southcott, A.J. | Boothby ,SA | Liberal |
| St Clair, S.R. | New England ,NSW | National |
| Stone, S.N. | Murray ,Vic | Liberal |
| Sullivan, K.J.M. | Moncrieff ,Qld | Liberal |
| Thompson, C.P. | Blair ,Qld | Liberal |
| Thomson, A.P. | Wentworth ,NSW | Liberal |
| Truss, W.E. | Wide Bay ,Qld | National |
| Tuckey, C.W. | O'Connor ,WA | Liberal |
| Vale, D.S. | Hughes ,NSW | Liberal |
| Wakelin, B.H. | Grey ,SA | Liberal |
| Washer, M.J. | Moore ,WA | Liberal |
| Williams, D.R. | Tangney ,WA | Liberal |
| Wooldridge, M.R.L. | Casey ,Vic | Liberal |
| Worth, P.M. | Adelaide ,SA | Liberal |
NOES
| Name | Electorate | Party Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| Adams, D.G.H. | Lyons, TAS | Labor |
| Albanese, A.N. | Grayndler, NSW | Labor |
| Andren, P.J. | Calare, NSW | None |
| Bevis, A.R. | Brisbane, QLD | Labor |
| Brereton, L.J. | Kingsford Smith, NSW | Labor |
| Burke, A.E. | Chisholm, VIC | Labor |
| Byrne, A.M. | Holt, VIC | Labor |
| Corcoran, A.K. | Isaacs, VIC | Labor |
| Cox, D.A. | Kingston, SA | Labor |
| Crean, S.F. | Hotham, VIC | Labor |
| Crosio, J.A. | Prospect, NSW | Labor |
| Danby, M. | Melbourne Ports, VIC | Labor |
| Ellis, A.L. | Canberra, ACT | Labor |
| Emerson, C.A. | Rankin, QLD | Labor |
| Evans, M.J. | Bonython, SA | Labor |
| Ferguson, L.D.T. | Reid, NSW | Labor |
| Ferguson, M.J. | Batman, VIC | Labor |
| Fitzgibbon, J.A. | Hunter, NSW | Labor |
| Gerick, J.F. | Canning, WA | Labor |
| Gibbons, S.W. | Bendigo, VIC | Labor |
| Gillard, J.E. | Lalor, VIC | Labor |
| Griffin, A.P. | Bruce, VIC | Labor |
| Hall, J.G. | Shortland, NSW | Labor |
| Hatton, M.J. | Blaxland, NSW | Labor |
| Hoare, K.J. | Charlton, NSW | Labor |
| Hollis, C. | Throsby, NSW | Labor |
| Irwin, J. | Fowler, NSW | Labor |
| Jenkins, H.A. | Scullin, VIC | Labor |
| Kerr, D.J.C. | Denison, TAS | Labor |
| Latham, M.W. | Werriwa, NSW | Labor |
| Lawrence, C.M. | Fremantle, WA | Labor |
| Lee, M.J. | Dobell, NSW | Labor |
| Livermore, K.F. | Capricornia, QLD | Labor |
| Macklin, J.L. | Jagajaga, VIC | Labor |
| Martin, S.P. | Cunningham, NSW | Labor |
| McClelland, R.B. | Barton, NSW | Labor |
| McFarlane, J.S. | Stirling, WA | Labor |
| McLeay, L.B. | Watson, NSW | Labor |
| McMullan, R.F. | Fraser, ACT | Labor |
| Melham, D. | Banks, NSW | Labor |
| Morris, A.A. | Newcastle, NSW | Labor |
| Mossfield, F.W. | Greenway, NSW | Labor |
| Murphy, J. P. | Lowe, NSW | Labor |
| O'Connor, G.M. | Corio, VIC | Labor |
| O'Keefe, N.P. | Burke, VIC | Labor |
| Plibersek, T. | Sydney, NSW | Labor |
| Price, L.R.S. | Chifley, NSW | Labor |
| Quick, H.V. | Franklin, TAS | Labor |
| Ripoll, B.F. | Oxley, QLD | Labor |
| Roxon, N.L. | Gellibrand, VIC | Labor |
| Sawford, R.W. | Port Adelaide, SA | Labor |
| Sercombe, R.C.G. | Maribyrnong, VIC | Labor |
| Short, L.M. | Ryan, QLD | Labor |
| Sidebottom, P.S. | Braddon, TAS | Labor |
| Smith, S.F. | Perth, WA | Labor |
| Snowdon, W.E. | Northern Territory, NT | Labor |
| Tanner, L. | Melbourne, VIC | Labor |
| Theophanous, A.C. | Calwell, VIC | None |
| Thomson, K.J. | Wills, VIC | Labor |
| Wilkie, K. | Swan, WA | Labor |
| Zahra, C.J. | McMillan, VIC | Labor |
The Senate
Ayes............ 30
Noes............ 34
Majority......... 4
AYES
| Name | State | Party Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| Abetz, E. | TAS | Liberal |
| Alston, R.K.R. | VIC | Liberal |
| Boswell, R.L.D. | QLD | National |
| Calvert, P.H. | TAS | Liberal |
| Chapman, H.G.P. | SA | Liberal |
| Coonan, H.L. | NSW | Liberal |
| Crane, A.W. | WA | Liberal |
| Eggleston, A. | WA | Liberal |
| Ellison, C.M. | WA | Liberal |
| Ferris, J.M. | SA | Liberal |
| Gibson, B.F. | TAS | Liberal |
| Harris, L. | QLD | One Nation |
| Heffernan, W. | NSW | Liberal |
| Herron, J.J. | QLD | Liberal |
| Hill, R.M. | SA | Liberal |
| Kemp, C.R. | VIC | Liberal |
| Knowles, S.C. | WA | Liberal |
| Lightfoot, P.R. | WA | Liberal |
| Macdonald, I. | QLD | Liberal |
| Macdonald, J.A.L. | NSW | National |
| McGauran, J.J.J. | VIC | National |
| Minchin, N.H. | SA | Liberal |
| Newman, J.M. | TAS | Liberal |
| Reid, M.E. | ACT | Liberal |
| Tambling, G.E. | NT | Country Liberal |
| Tchen, T. | VIC | Liberal |
| Tierney, J.W. | NSW | Liberal |
| Troeth, J.M. | VIC | Liberal |
| Vanstone, A.E. | SA | Liberal |
| Watson, J.O.W. | TAS | Liberal |
NOES
| Name | State | Party Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| Allison, L.F. | VIC | Democrat |
| Bartlett, A.J.J. | QLD | Democrat |
| Bishop, T.M. | WA | Labor |
| Bolkus, N. | SA | Labor |
| Brown, B.J. | TAS | Green |
| Buckland, G. | SA | Labor |
| Campbell, G. | NSW | Labor |
| Carr, K.J. | VIC | Labor |
| Cherry, J.C. | QLD | Democrat |
| Conroy, S.M. | VIC | Labor |
| Cook, P.F.S. | WA | Labor |
| Cooney, B.C. | VIC | Labor |
| Crossin, P.M. | NT | Labor |
| Crowley, R.A. | SA | Labor |
| Denman, K.J. | TAS | Labor |
| Evans, C.V. | WA | Labor |
| Faulkner, J.P. | NSW | Labor |
| Forshaw, M.G. | NSW | Labor |
| Greig, B. | WA | Democrat |
| Harradine, B. | TAS | None |
| Hogg, J.J. | QLD | Labor |
| Hutchins, S.P. | NSW | Labor |
| Lees, M.H. | SA | Democrat |
| Ludwig, J.W. | QLD | Labor |
| Mackay, S.M. | TAS | Labor |
| McKiernan, J.P. | WA | Labor |
| McLucas, J.E. | QLD | Labor |
| Murphy, S.M. | TAS | Labor |
| Murray, A.J.M. | WA | Democrat |
| O'Brien, K.W.K. | TAS | Labor |
| Ray, R.F. | VIC | Labor |
| Sherry, N.J. | TAS | Labor |
| Stott Despoja, N. | SA | Democrat |
| West, S.M. | NSW | Labor |
Court Cases
- The judgement of the Federal Court in a case brought on behalf of the refugees on the M.V. Tampa.